ZIP Code 12458

Monticello, NY — income, home value, property tax, and sales tax.

Median household income
$64,851
Per-capita income
$20,964
Median home value
$352,500
Property tax rate
1.77%
Combined sales tax
8.00%

In ZIP code 12458, near Monticello, households bring in a median of $64,851 a year, while per-capita income sits at $20,964 — a gap that hints at a mix of household sizes and earners. With the median home valued at $200,700 and the county property tax rate at 1.77%, owners face roughly $3,550 in annual property taxes. Add the 8.00% combined sales tax on purchases, and everyday spending carries a noticeable premium. Together these costs shape how far a paycheck stretches across housing, goods, and services in this area.

See how Monticello, NY taxes stack up

These numbers change over time. Get an update when they do — plus our recommendations.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.